Psychology-Driven Brand Design. Creating and Refining Remarkable Brand Identities.

One Simple Way to Raise More Money for Your Nonprofit

Table of Contents

Whereas a for-profit business may be selling products or services, a nonprofit organization is generally selling a cause or an ideal. And it takes a little something extra to convince people to give up their money without receiving anything quantifiable in return. In either case, however, both groups need to consider their communication and understand the psychology driving their consumer’s mindset.

How do you get people to give?

The driving force behind at least 99% of a nonprofit’s marketing efforts is to encourage people to give. The question that should be asked, however, is what should a nonprofit ask a donor to give – time or money? Believe it or not, there can be a marked difference in the amount of money a nonprofit can raise if they get this one question right.

This question has been researched in both field and lab experiments across different populations, detailed in “The Happiness of Giving: The Time-Ask Effect“. The overwhelming result has been that by first asking people about giving time (as opposed to an initial ask for money), those people will be more inclined to give more money when they actually do contribute financially. Note that they don’t even have to give of their time for this to manifest — the very act of them thinking about whether they will volunteer is often enough for this effect to be realized.

Why is this so?

The explanation for this behavior hinges on the hypothesis that time and money activate different beliefs and mindsets in us — an emotional mindset versus a quantifiable, value-maximizing mindset.

Time = Experiences

We tend to measure time not only in seconds and hours, but in experiences. Experiences come with rich emotional associations. In addition, people prefer to give their time when a cause has a high personal significance – meaning that volunteering is tied to our identity and emotional wellness. Therefore, considering giving of your time activates your goals of emotional well-being and personal significance in this world. In other words, when people are asked if they would consider giving of their time, they instinctively start to think about what the experience means to them. It triggers their emotional mindset.

Even though time is a finite resource, the value of a person’s time is more ambiguous than the set value of money. Consider: if given the choice to spend the weekend having a family picnic in the park or working overtime in the office, it is up to you and only you to determine which is a good use of your time. And that boils down to what the experience is worth to you. Nobody else can tell you that; it’s purely subjective.

Money = Scrutiny

On the other hand, money is more clearly quantified, in economic terms. We tend to have a higher level of scrutiny when it comes to giving of our money: What will I get in return? What will my money be used for? How exactly will it help fill a need? Is it simply going to pad the pockets of the CEO? When we part with money, we demand 100% satisfaction, don’t we? If we buy a product, and it turns out to be defective, we will demand our money back, right? We are more careful with how we part with our money, and we are more critical of its worth when we do part with it. When we think about money, we activate a quantifiable, value-maximizing mindset.

The ask.

The research suggests that even though we seem to have a tighter grip on our money, once emotions are “activated” by an ask for time, a subsequent ask for money seems to be connected to that initial emotional mindset. And therefore, people are more willing to give (and in higher amounts). Thus, if you want to increase donations to your organization, you should ask people for their time, not just their money.

Of course this is not a magic bullet for instant riches; it’s to be put into practice as part of a long-term strategy to attract more funds over time. Nor is it an underhanded way of manipulating people — it’s simply something to understand about what makes people tick. Basically it comes down to: if people are engaged, they act — even if they are only engaged emotionally in their subconscious.

How to apply this knowledge to your nonprofit’s marketing

So, what should your takeaway be from this? In your marketing materials, the goal should be to engage people emotionally first, before even asking for money. This may be, as in the study, asking plainly, “Would you consider volunteering your time?” and having them actively respond. Or it may be woven more subtly throughout your strategy, such as creating an emotional connection through displaying stories and testimonials of the people you’ve helped. And remember: before you can expect people to give anything, you must first prove to them why you are worthy of giving to. Nonprofit marketing should be trustworthy — professional, but not so flashy that it causes people to wonder if you’re frivolously spending money on unnecessary bells and whistles instead of on your true cause.

This study is yet another confirmation that emotional connections are what you want to strive for. Emotional associations can and will influence people’s behavior. The lesson for both nonprofits and for-profits alike is that emotional connections are more powerful than facts, figures, or a list of fancy features could ever be on their own.

Nyla Smith

Nyla Smith

Nyla is a Graphic Designer, Web Designer, Front-End Web Developer and Consultant with over 15 years of experience. She is the owner of n-Vision Designs, LLC in Hampton Roads, Virginia, which exists to provide marketing support and brand consulting to small- and medium-sized businesses needing creative solutions. Contact Nyla if you'd like to discuss your next creative project. She can usually be bribed to a meeting with a cup of green tea and an oatmeal cookie.

More Like This...

Don’t Blame Google for Your Bad Website

I came across a discussion on an online forum where a business owner was complaining that he spent all of his hard-earned money on Google AdWords yet saw nary a profit. He blasted Google, which (merited or not in other cases), I wasn’t convinced was the real problem here.

Read More »

“E” is for: Email Marketing

Prior to 1971, nobody knew what email was. In 2012, we sent 294 BILLION emails per day. Love it or hate it, email is now a part of our daily lives. For businesses, email is one of the primary marketing vehicles for reaching customers. It is a cost-effective way to send targeted, personalized, and automated messages.

Read More »